Television is not dead, but more often now, it comes in doses. Very few of the shows I watch are made into full seasons. Of course, a lot of them are on cable and don't have to follow the old fall-to-spring timeline. Of those, only a few have more than 10-15 episodes. TV is going niche, and there just aren't that many people getting 22 or so episodes a year to spell out things. You have to do it in a few months. Thus, it makes sense for this armchair critic to hand out awards for the first half (or second half, if you go by seasons) of the year.
Well, what a half it was! A lot of shows I had been eagerly anticipating came back. Most did not disappoint. I don't know what I'll do in the fall, but then, there's this thing the Americans call football. I suppose I'll just have to get used to it, because it's clear that great shows only come so often.
I will mention a few year-round comedies that have my attention. 30 Rock is finally living up to the critical hype. How I Met Your Mother is goofy and a bit cliched but still enjoyable. The Office became the unlikeliest landing spot for some former Wire stars, but they helped spark some life into it. That's pretty much it. Most everything I like comes in spurts.
Onto the winners...
BEST COMEDIES
1. Delocated - Adult Swim decided to support a few live-action shows that fit their particular (stoner/slacker/college) sense of humor, and it paid off. This mock-reality show about a man in witness relocation (which is a hilariously stupid premise in itself) is great for Jon Glaser's awkward humor, especially with his assigned protector / timid buddy. Eugene Mirman is great as a Russian assassin, and there were some great cameos.
2. Eastbound & Down - Danny McBride's sudden appearance on the comedy scene comes from the cult success of The Foot Fist Way. He & his pals behind that created this show with the same kind of dark humor. Basically, they're taking the approach of a lot of recent Apatow & Will Ferrell movies and then putting it into series form.... which is great. Being on HBO frees them to be dark and vulgar, and they use that. Personal fave Andrew Daly is great as the uptight principal.
3. Important Things with Demetri Martin - I always liked Demetri's stand up, and I was curious to see how he would translate it into a full show. It works because he mixes sketches with some stand up and weird tidbits. He brought in Adult Swim veteran Jon Benjamin to be his go-to guy, which was smart. John Oliver of The Daily Show also added some great moments.
4. The Mighty Boosh - Yes, I know, it doesn't quite count as a regular entry because it was already on TV for several years in Britain. A lot of people have already seen it, and Adult Swim is replaying episodes from a span of several seasons. Still, this is a new revelation to some, and having it on a regular screen (and not having to rely on YouTube clips) makes my day brighter.
5. Flight of the Conchords - Bret and Jemaine's second season was filled with more star appearances, but maybe not as good as the first. They are most likely finished with this show. No matter, though, because their live shows are great and they have a growing fan base now. That's the way to see them.
BEST DRAMAS
1. Lost - Look, either you like it or you don't. I'm not trying to convince anyone. I just love it. I wish that it was on all year... they could have used more episodes to flesh out the mile-a-minute story and better add to the new characters. It's still my number one addiction.
2. Damages - This is a show that people need to watch. It's replaced The Shield as FX's showcase, intense drama. Last season was a dive into paranoia and the powerful, unseen forces that drive society. This season, it focused more on a great story, while still building on the existing troubles. A lot of great actors joined the cast. Watch it.
3. Big Love - HBO's polygamist drama has gone in some weird places, but it's worth it. It took a while to find a proper tone, but it mixes family drama with cultish conspiracy.
4. Dollhouse - Joss Whedon is gold. His new project takes sci-fi but adds a deep emotional core. He plays with the idea of self and identity as people become objects. It picked up steam as the season went along and thankfully got a renewal.
5. Fringe - OK, this was actually on all year. It took a long break, however, and the spring session was much better than the fall. It separated itself from an X Files ripoff to become a fascinating sci-fi epic.
MOST DISAPPOINTING
1. Life on Mars - This was the ultimate borderline show for me. I was on the fence about keeping up with it all year. It had some really cheesy moments, but the cast was impressive and they had cool music. Once I learned it was going to wrap everything up in one season, I decided to stick it out. Big mistake. It ended with one of the most confusing and infuriating finales ever. It wasn't a thoughtful ambiguous ending, it was an ending that had no place and completely undermined the emotional pull that the whole series was trying to build. ABC, you wasted many hours of my life and I want them back. You're lucky you have Lost.
2. Heroes - Do I even need to say anything? I do have some questions. Hey, remember how Sylar was tricked into believing he was one of the Petrellis last year? Did that have any importance at all? Why won't they just get rid of Ali Larter? Am I a bad person for really hating Masi Oka now?
3. Scrubs - I still kinda like this show, but its supposed end has been dragged out and apparently still isn't happening yet. They could have ended on NBC, but signed on for another half-year at ABC, then tried to end it, but now are coming back. This show is okay, but it's not good enough to keep on this long.
4. Parks & Recreation - It's too early to tell, but a show with this many good people in it should be funnier. I'm hoping it gets better.
5. Sit Down, Shut Up - Perhaps the most bizarre of shows to get a run. It didn't look great on its own in previews, and it isn't. But the talent level behind this is amazing - Mitch Hurwitz assembled writers from AD and even prime-era Simpsons, then coaxed a strong name cast to do voices. Still, it sucked. Why was THIS his big return to TV? Did he do this just to stick it to FOX? I'm perplexed.
That does it for the spring session. There are a few summer shows coming up that will hopefully bridge me to another season. Of course, I don't have The Wire to get me through those lonely summer days this year. Oh well.

